Baking with kids at Christmas is less about the result and more about the flour on the floor and the smell in the house. These three bakes forgive a lot, taste good anyway, and produce a plate for Santa on Christmas Eve.
Butter tarts
Buy the tart shells; make the filling. Butter, brown sugar, an egg, a splash of vanilla and a spoon of corn syrup, whisked together, poured into the shells with or without raisins (this is a national argument; do not expect to settle it), and baked until the tops are just set and the edges bubble. Kids do the pouring and the arguing.
Shortbread
Three ingredients: butter, sugar, flour. Cream the butter and sugar, work in the flour, press into a pan or roll and cut with cookie cutters, prick with a fork, bake low until pale gold. Decorate with sprinkles before baking or icing after. The dough is forgiving enough for a three-year-old.
A gingerbread house that stays up
Kits are fine; the trick is the glue. Melt sugar in a pan until it is amber, dip the edges of the walls in it (grown-ups only; it is very hot), and hold for ten seconds. The house will stand through New Year. Then hand the kids the royal icing and the candy and leave the room.
Nanaimo bars, if you are from the West
No baking at all: a crumb base, a custard middle, chocolate on top, chilled. Kids can do every layer. They are also the thing most likely to be gone by Christmas Eve.
The plate for Santa
Whatever you bake, save a few for the plate on Christmas Eve, with a glass of milk and a carrot for the reindeer. A homemade butter tart with a bite out of it in the morning is proof that Santa came, and that he approved. If Santa has called that week and asked them to leave something out, the plate gets arranged with extra care.